Hi. My name is Daniel Crandall, and I’m a Biblio-holic. When I go into a bookstore I often lose the struggle against the urge to buy more books. When I moved, I had to unload 600 pounds of books (only a small dent in my collection) so the moving company’s forklift could get the storage container onto their truck. I wrestled with selling many of these books to a used bookstore. In the end, I traded them for store credit, which means, of course, I can get more books.
I find myself living Erasmus’s alleged quote, “When I get a little money I buy books; and if any is left I buy food and clothes.”
I. Love. Books.
I’m not certain I can love Amazon’s Kindle or Barnes and Nobles’ Nook. Ever since these electronic reading devices hit the stores I resisted them like all good bound-book-loving Luddites. I snobbishly turn away from the Nook counter prominently located near the entrance to many Barnes and Nobles.
I would rather flip pages than press a button to “flip” screens. You can keep your bytes as long as I can ‘bite’ into a good paperback or hardcover text.
Libby Malin Sternberg wrote the first piece that makes me seriously reconsider my antagonism to this new-fangled technology. Ms. Malin Sternberg
“went to [her] massive library of reference materials, and, after many hours of exhilarating research, [she] came up with several missives sent over the years during periods of great change in the world of printed communications.”
Do I really wanted to be associated with Luddites of centuries past such as this:
Fifteenth century epistle from an older monk at an Alsatian monastery, Schwer-an-Merde, to another younger monk in a nearby German abbey:
“. . . . Please try harder to color within the lines, dear Frere Aefle. Your latest efforts were a strange mess of colors in odd cube-like forms that reminded me of images seen through shards of glass. But I must say at least it was better than the blurry pictures you did on the previous manuscript. That one created mere impressions, rather than a specific image. It made one feel as if one were viewing a landscape through wine-besotted eyes. Dear Abbot Pierre exclaimed after seeing it: Je vais chercher du bon vin a la cave. (Editor’s note: the loose translation for this phrase is, ‘This looks to be written with wine. I must search for some wine. Wine is good. Very good. Very, very good. Is it five o’clock somewhere?’) Such shoddy workmanship on your part will only feed the talk that our efforts are useless decoration and unnecessary toil, especially now that villagers are all in a fever over the printing machine you described. Gutenberg, Schmutenberg, my dear Frere Aefle. Even your most pitiful illumination efforts are more vibrant than the cold images of letters on paper I’ve seen coming from his machine. No, dear Frere, rest assured nothing will replace our artistic efforts. And even if Herr Schmutenburg’s device takes hold, I have been told by dear Friar Chuck that such ‘presses’ will still need laborers like us. He has devised a plan to work together with the Glutenbergs, something he is calling ‘the agency model,’ providing manuscripts to the presses for distribution . It is very complicated. But the important thing to remember, mon Frere, is to keep toiling away, perfecting your craft and trusting Friar Chuck and all the Abbots to look after us. . . “
Read more examples of past Luddites who struggled against “a change in the world of printed communication” at Libbysbooks. Ms. Malin Sternberg finally convinced me to seriously consider setting down the printed page and pick up one of these … devices.
I do wonder, however, if browsing a bookstore will someday be like wandering through an antique shop or museum where used books are carefully preserved. Will our posterity stare in amazement at how their ancestors held and read .such ‘weighty’ tomes.
Thanks for the Luddite book tips. I’ll be sure to look them up, and not on a Kindle.
Btw, I do not own one, and there are no plans to buy one in the near future. I’d like to see their price come down more. I also don’t think they will replace paper bound books, at least not in my lifetime or even in the next generation’s lifetime. Two or Three generations down the road … ? Who knows.
And you’re right about e-readers being great devices for readers who travel. It’s a great way to bring along several books without the possibility of a hernia.
For anyone who depends on them … one EMP and one’s entire library is gone in a flash.
PS. The Luddites get a bad rap. Check out the books “Against the Machine,” “Rebels Against the Future” and “The Plain Reader” for the other side of the story.
Great piece, Daniel. I continue to count myself among the ranks of those who actively resist the Kindle. I’m not opposed to the _idea_ of the Kindle, but Mr. Bezos (Amazon CEO) has made some alarming statements recently about his long-term goals for the Kindle eventually replacing books altogether.
I would prefer to see the Kindle coexist happily with paper books rather than replace them–an efficient alternative for readers who travel a lot. And in all likelihood, that’s what will happen. However, I cannot abide by a marketing plan that openly targets paper books for extinction–even if that onerous goal doesn’t come to fruition.
I plan on exploring this more in a longer piece down the road. Thanks for the thought-provoking read!
“Forced?” How? If you don’t want a Kindle or Nook or Sony e-Book reader, there’s a simple solution: Don’t buy one. No one is forcing the “change” on you.
And responding to changing technology has nothing to do with being conservative or liberal. Unless you want to claim that only liberals embraced that new-fangled horseless carriage, while conservatives obstinately stuck to their horse and buggies. Or that conservatives should have stuck with broadcast television and ignored the growth of cable television. Or conservatives should have bitterly clung to newspapers and left that internet craze to those crazy liberal young people.
😉
Imagine if the Kindle and Sony e-Reader are an avenue to creating a culture of liberty and personal responsibility. Should we ignore it for no other reason than it’s new?
The problem I have with the Kindle and E-books in general is that it’s change forced on us, and needless change at that – the Kindle satisfies only the needs it creates. As a conservative I’m wary of this be-modern-or-be-a-dork mentality that permeates our digital modernity – and don’t get me started with the Iphone or the Ipad. I’ll buy a Kindle if and only if there is no other option left. Since then I stuck to my old paper book. I’m curious about your eventual experience, though.
[…] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Daniel Crandall, Mon. Mon said: Books,Book and Books Convincing a Book-Loving Luddite to Pick Up a Kindle: The American Culture You… http://bit.ly/a8u8H0 mybookstop.info […]