The comedian George Carlin should be remembered for his silly humor, not his politics.
The comedian George Carlin died yesteday at the age of 71. To the general public, he was known more for controversies over obscenity in his act than for his comedy—his "Seven Words You Can’t Say on Television" monologue led to a 1978 U.S. Supreme Court decision affirming that the FCC could regulate obscenity and punish broadcasters for presenting offensive language during hours when children might be listening.
Influenced strongly by the intellectually and socially ambitious comedian Lenny Bruce, who fancied himself a brilliant satirist, Carlin decided early on to make himself into a similarly aggressive social commentator, with a particular emphasis on ridiculing all things bourgeois, as Bruce had done. As AP notes:
Carlin started his career on the traditional nightclub circuit in a coat and tie, pairing with [Jack] Burns to spoof TV game shows, news and movies. Perhaps in spite of the outlaw soul, ‘‘George was fairly conservative when I met him,’’ said Burns, describing himself as the more left-leaning of the two. It was a degree of separation that would reverse when they came upon Lenny Bruce, the original shock comic, in the early ’60s.
‘‘We were working in Chicago, and we went to see Lenny, and we were both blown away,’’ Burns said, recalling the moment as the beginning of the end for their collaboration if not their close friendship. ‘‘It was an epiphany for George. The comedy we were doing at the time wasn’t exactly groundbreaking, and George knew then that he wanted to go in a different direction.’’
That direction would make Carlin as much a social commentator and philosopher as comedian, a position he would relish through the years.
Carlin’s social commentary came from a left-wing atheist perspective perfectly attuned to the cynical spirit of the 1960s and all but guaranteed to appeal to the nation’s critics, who were monolithically leftist themselves. Carlin’s greatest bugaboo was religion, in particular an ignorant and absurd caricature of Christianity. The AP story quotes Carlin on his point of view, in a statement he made in 2004:
‘‘The whole problem with this idea of obscenity and indecency, and all of these things—bad language and whatever—it’s all caused by one basic thing, and that is: religious superstition,’’ Carlin said in a 2004 interview. ‘‘There’s an idea that the human body is somehow evil and bad and there are parts of it that are especially evil and bad, and we should be ashamed. Fear, guilt and shame are built into the attitude toward sex and the body…. It’s reflected in these prohibitions and these taboos that we have.’’
When he downplayed his pretensions toward being a philosopher, satirist, and political thinker, Carlin was quite funny. His humor started out simply silly, pointing out odd contradictions in modern life, and that was always his best vein of humor.
It is for that legacy, not his political activism and ignorant antireligious prejudice, that Carlin should be remembered—for his humor will last after the political issues are long dead.
I laughed when I heard Carlin had passed away. I wonder how well his act was received by GOD, when he was called before God’s throne.
Carlin did more to turn people away from God than he ever did for promoting God’s word.
I would have loved to be on the sidelines to watch that performance.
Dan–Your translation is faulty. I disagree with George Carlin’s pretensions toward being a philosopher, satirist, and political thinker. I think his positions on those issues both wrong and ignorant. I agree with his implied positions on numerous other issues regarding the contradictions inherent in modern liberal bourgeois life. And just as I’m sure you’d defend to the death Carlin’s right to denigrate whatever he did not like, you would defend to the death my right to point out that he was hopelessly lame and weak in his political thinking while being highly talented at creating humor. Yes, I’m quite sure of that.
Translation (for both the original post and Sam’s comment): “I disagree with George Carlin.”
I quite agree, Mike. The gift of humor is so rare and precious that it’s a shame when people who have it look down on it or use it to do something they see as more important. Mark Twain fell into the same trap, and his work became tendentious, pretentious, and dull. And Carlin was no Twain.
Sam:
I’ve always maintained that the cardinal mistake comedians make is taking themselves too seriously.
Carlin went from being a funny young man to a grumpy old man rather rapidly, I thought. “Philosopher”? Who said that? Where’s his proof?
Now that Carlin’s playing a venue out of town, I wonder how well his act is going over.
Best regards,
Mike Tooney