“It snowed all day and all night. On the 22nd it was still snowing. Snowballs flew, snowmen grew. Sceptical children regained their belief in fairyland, and sour adults felt like Santa Claus, buying more presents than they had ever intended. In the evening the voice of the announcer, traveling through endless white ether, informed the millions that more snow was coming….
More snow came. It floated down from its limitless source like a vast extinguisher. Sweepers, eager for their harvest, waited in vain for the snow to stop. People wondered whether it ever would stop.”
–Jefferson Farjeon, Mystery in White (1937)
People stranded in a country house cut off from the outside world by snow, with murderous events afoot. It’s a classic and beloved Golden Age murder mystery scenario and it’s one Jefferson Farjeon used in his 1937 thriller Mystery in White. To top it all off, the tale takes place over Christmas eve and Christmas day.
As the splendid dust jacket reveals, a train is involved too, albeit briefly. Like Agatha Christie’s Orient Express, this train gets stalled by snow. Five passengers–a clerk, a chorus girl, an elderly paranormal investigator and a genteel brother and sister–make their way off the train with their luggage to find a connection at a nearby station.
The wayfarers get lost in the snow, of course, but providentially they come upon a large country house, front door unlocked. No one seems to be in the house (though what was that noise in the attic?!), but fires are set and the table is properly laid for tea (though what’s that bread knife doing on the floor…).
In short, we, the readers, are encountering a favorite Jefferson Farjeon thriller scenario: stranded people encountering mystery and murder in an isolated building (this pattern goes all the way back to the author’s 1920s mystery play No. 17, later filmed by Alfred Hitchcock; see also such novels as Sinister Inn and The Windmill Mystery). Queer noises occur, strangers–some perhaps malevolent–wander in and out, mysterious circumstances pile up like the snow drifts outside the house. By adding Christmas to the mix, Farjeon has made a cozily creepy mystery nog for our delectation. Not over-taxing for the brain, but enjoyable nevertheless.
“Jefferson Farjeon is quite unsurpassed for creepy skill in mysterious adventures,” Dorothy L. Sayers once proclaimed of one of her favorite mystery writers, gifting Farjeon’s publishers on both sides of the Atlantic with a pleasing blurb for years to come. Other critics who shared Sayers’ esteem for Farjeon were the American author and playwright Paul Wilstach (“Jefferson Farjeon writes corkers….He inevitably gives delight”) and the American critic and scholar William Lyon Phelps (“Jefferson Farjeon is one of my favorite providers of murder. He knows how to give distinction…by an excellent literary style”).
English thriller tales from the 1920s and 1930s generally have a bad reputation today, frequently being condemned for their exhibitions of racism and xenophobia. Certainly this is true of much of the work of the egregious Sydney Horler, say, or the more talented but still sometimes admittedly quite objectionable H. C. McNeile (“Sapper”).
Yet Jefferson Farjeon’s thrillers tend to be more gentle and whimsical (even as the body count rises).
Farjeon himself by all accounts was a mild and kindhearted man, the son of Benjamin Farjeon (1838-1903)–a popular Victorian author who venerated Charles Dickens–and himself a vegetarian and pacifist (his Cold War apocalyptic sci-fi novel, Death of a World, is a passionate protest against the post-WW2 arms race). Surely not unexpectedly, his thrillers reflect his family background and personality.
In Mystery in White, Farjeon presents his chorus girl and clerk with empathy (in one chapter a Walter Mitty-like fantasy sequence representing the fever-dream of the clerk is quite amusingly done), though in this one the genteel brother and sister play more active roles. Events get quite tangled, but all finally is revealed (though not really deduced).
The dilatory police eventually do show up near the end of the novel, but in another resemblance to Agatha Christie’s And Then There Were None England’s finest don’t get things quite right.
In addition to And Then There Were None, Mystery in White also somewhat resembles the celebrated Christie play The Mousetrap, though it must be admitted that it’s neither as clever nor as sinister. But Christie fans (and all “cozy” English mystery fans) should enjoy this representative Farjeon tale. It’s not his best, but it makes a nice holiday Golden Age mystery treat.
For more on Jefferson Farjeon, see http://thepassingtramp.blogspot.com/2011/11/another-pass-by-jefferson-farjeon-1883.html and http://thepassingtramp.blogspot.com/2011/11/passing-tramp.html.
Originally published at The Passing Tramp. Reprinted with author’s permission.